I MAY HAVE OVER ANALYSED THIS BUT………..

Obviously Uhtred would beat Derfel simply because he is  much nastier character.

Derfel would easily beat Sharpe, who as we know beats Harper and easily beats Starbuck!

Thomas of Hookton beats them all apart from Derfel and Uhtred (archers muscles)

And finally Steappa kicks everybody’s ass.

Hope that clears things up.

Mike