Auto Draft

Hello Bernard

I recently had a slight disagreement with someone over your Starbuck Chronicles. He said that he felt that reading the Starbuck Chronicles (without prior knowledge of the US civil war) duped him into believing the lost cause myth that the war was really about state writes and not about slavery.

My counterpoint to this was that Nathaniel knows he is on the wrong side but only continues with it due to he determination to do the ultimate act of rebellion against his father. And that’s what made the series interesting Nathaniel a good man fighting for a bad cause, contrasted with his Father Elias Starbuck a horrible man fighting for a good cause.

Sorry to drag you into this but I wonder was that assumption the reason you choose to write from the Confederate perspective.

Thank you

Patrick Ashby