Dear Bernard
I saw this question debates as a great what if of history and wondered what your own thoughts were if who was the greater General The Iron Duke or the Iron Marshal ?. Wellington victories are well known but Davout victory at Auerstedt was pretty incredible as was his victory against Archdule Charles at Eckmuhl.
So who would be your pick ?
Geraint
P.S You said you were often tempted to get Sharpe to Austerlitz how about Auerstedt instead ?