Dear Mr. Cornwell I'm a great fan of all your books and beg you never to cease writing but my question is about Pinkerton in the Starbuck series. I have never read a factual account of anything Pinkerton did, or any of his exploits. In your books you depict him as an affable fool, who in my mind seems unsuited to field work, however in other accounts of him from other novels or films (no actual factual sources) I have seen him depicted as anything from a stonecold killer field agent taking down the greatest bandits of the West to an extremely intelligent desk man of the greatest abilities providing the US with vital services and intelligence. I was wondering whether your account of him was based on true evidence and facts or if it was simply how it was easiest for you to depict him? If the latter is so, would you be kind enough to give me some details of what he was truly like. Thanks, sorry it's a bit longwinded.
Tom Brown
A bumbler. Might have been a cold-hearted bumbler, but bumbler he was. It was Pinkerton who fed McClellan's fantasies about the Confederate numbers - all smoke and mirrors. There are good sources on Pinkerton and I'd refer them if I could, but I'm on vacation in Australia right now so I'm helpless.